The Good and Not So Bad Foods for Cognitive Health
October 2nd, 2009 · by Simon Evans · Filed Under: Uncategorized
We all know that our diet affects our health, and hopefully, if you’ve been reading this blog, you also realize that diet plays a role in cognitive health while you age. We’ve focused many articles in the past on the role of various nutrients in boosting cognitive function.
A new study in the Journal of Nutrition took a somewhat different approach to look at overall diet quality (and lack there of) in healthy cognitive aging; as opposed to focusing on specific nutrients as most studies do. The results were interesting because they suggested that eating good food helps you age better, but eating not so good food doesn’t matter so much.
The research team from Utah State University recruited several thousand people over the age of 65 and gave them a questionnaire about the foods they typically eat. They then separated these people into four groups based on intake of ‘recommended foods’. Those that ate the most recommended foods were in the first group, those that ate the least amount of recommended foods in the fourth group, while intermediate intakes of recommended foods placed people in groups two and three. Recommended foods we’re all the standard stuff, like whole grains, fruits and vegetables, lean protein, low-fat dairy, and non-fried fish.
Researchers then implemented cognitive tests to all the participants and found that groups who ate more recommended foods performed better than those who ate less of the recommended foods. But they weren’t done yet. The research team followed the participants for an average of 11 years and found that the differences between groups were exaggerated over time.
While all the groups performed less well after 11 years than they did at the beginning of the study (since they were getting older), those who ate more recommended foods declined much slower than those who at less good stuff. In other words, we all get a little slower as we age, but those who get good doses of good foods can expect a much kinder slope than those who don’t.
There was one more surprising bit to this study. The researchers also looked at how eating non-recommended foods influenced initial cognitive performance and decline over the 11 year period, and found no association. That is, people who ate more poor foods did not fare worse than those who ate less poor foods.
How is this possible? Essentially, this research suggests is that eating good foods is more important than not eating bad foods. In other words, if you get a good dose of all the recommended stuff, then a death by chocolate cake now and again isn’t a big deal. However, if you live on a staple of hotdogs and French fries (or freedom fries for those who still hold a grudge, another unhealthy behavior), then you probably don’t have the buffer necessary to fight off the ill effects of other poor choices.
In fact, in this study the group who ate the largest amount of recommended foods, also tended to eat more non-recommended foods. This seems to get back to the whole argument that we have been making for some time now of incorporating variety into your diet (and other aspects of your life). That said, you still want to keep your total calorie intake down so you don’t gain weight. Just because you eat a big healthy meal, doesn’t mean that a whopping dessert won’t pack a caloric punch. That’s a whole different question.
The bottom line is to work on getting high quality foods into your diet to help protect your cognitive health and don’t stress out on the occasion that you want something a little more sinful.
Reference: J. Nutrition, 139:1944-1949, 2009
How did you like this post?
Access our FREE 6-part BrainFit Mini-Course




















